Handling Refunds and Disputes for AI API Usage

If you run an AI API, refunds and disputes are not edge cases. They show up in every usage based business. If you do not handle them cleanly, your revenue, margins, and payment processor risk score start to drift in ways that are hard to unwind.

This guide gives you a simple, consistent way to handle refunds and chargebacks for AI usage from both an operations and accounting angle.

Last updated: December 2025

---

Where AI usage refunds come from

AI API refund requests usually fall into a few buckets:

• Billing bugs
• Misconfigurations or runaway usage on the customer side
• Outages or bad responses on your side
• Buyers who did not understand the pricing model
• Fraud or stolen payment methods

Tag every refund with a reason. Do this early. Later on you will want to know whether your refunds come from product issues, pricing confusion, or fraud.

---

Provider view: accounting for AI refunds

You are the provider. You bill for AI usage, either through your own metering or a provider like Stripe.

There are two main accounting questions:

1. Are you refunding usage that was already recognized as revenue?
2. Are you refunding unused prepaid credits that are still sitting in deferred revenue?

The journal entries are different.

Refund of already recognized AI usage

Example:

• Last month you billed 20,000 dollars of AI usage
• The customer is right and you agree to refund 2,000

If the customer already paid:

• Debit: Refunds (contra revenue) 2,000
• Credit: Cash 2,000

If they have not paid yet and you cancel the invoice:

• Debit: Refunds (contra revenue) 2,000
• Credit: Accounts receivable 2,000

Keeping refunds separate from usage revenue matters. It helps you track gross usage, refunds, and net revenue clearly.

If you can claw back model or infra costs from upstream vendors, adjust COGS. If you cannot, your gross margin takes the hit.

Refund of unused prepaid credits

If you sell prepaid credits, you likely treated the upfront cash as deferred revenue.

When you refund unused credits:

• Debit: Deferred revenue 2,000
• Credit: Cash 2,000

No revenue impact, because you never earned that part.

If the customer used part of the pack:

• The unused portion reduces deferred revenue
• The used portion hits refunds (contra revenue)

You need accurate per customer credit balances to do this cleanly.

---

Chargebacks and card disputes for AI usage

Sometimes customers skip your support team and dispute a charge with their bank. This becomes a chargeback.

Cardholders in the US have specific rights to dispute unauthorized charges and certain billing errors. Relevant primary sources include:

• Consumer Financial Protection Bureau – Disputing Credit Card Charges
• Federal Trade Commission – Credit Card Billing Errors

From your side, the usual flow:

1. Customer disputes a charge with their bank
2. Your processor reverses the payment
3. You accept it or submit evidence
4. You may pay a dispute fee

Simple chargeback accounting

Assume:

• You billed 500 dollars of AI usage
• Customer paid
• You already recorded revenue

When you lose the dispute:

• Debit: Chargeback loss or refunds 500
• Debit: Processing fees (chargeback fee)
• Credit: Cash (500 + fee)

If you already wrote down the receivable because you flagged the activity as fraud earlier, the chargeback simply clears what is left.

Evidence worth keeping

You cannot win every case, but clear logs help.

Keep:

• Timestamps of API calls
• Customer and user ids
• Input/output token counts
• Result logs or status codes
• Pricing page screenshots
• Support threads where customers acknowledged usage

When a large customer disputes a week of AI spend, being able to show “here are the calls and here is the exact usage” changes the conversation.

---

Writing a refund policy for AI usage

Write your policy before you need it. Be specific about:

• Time window for refunds
• Whether you refund misconfigurations that caused token spikes
• How you handle outages or broken responses
• When you offer credits vs cash refunds

A simple rule set that works well:

• Full refunds for billing bugs and double charges
• Credits or discounts for outages or degraded quality
• Case by case handling for unusually large usage bills

Post the policy in plain language. Make sure support, sales, and your terms page all say the same thing.

---

Keeping your AI revenue metrics honest

Do not bury refunds and chargebacks inside a single revenue line.

Track:

• Gross AI usage revenue
• Refunds
• Chargeback losses
• Net AI usage revenue

Break these down by:

• Customer
• Cohort
• Plan
• Reason code

Watch for patterns:

• High refund rates on certain plans
• Disputes clustering in specific geographies
• Recurring misconfigurations that point to UX problems

Patterns matter more than one noisy month.

---

Tax view of AI refunds

Refunds generally reduce taxable income, but the timing depends on your accounting method.

Primary IRS sources:

• IRS Publication 538 – Accounting Periods and Methods
• IRS Publication 535 – Business Expenses

High level:

• Cash method: you include income when received and reduce income when refunds are paid.
• Accrual method: you include income when earned and record refunds when your obligation to refund becomes fixed.

Because AI usage revenue can mix prepaid credits and variable usage, check with your tax advisor before making changes.

(This section is general information, not tax advice.)

---

A simple workflow that actually works

You do not need complicated systems on day one. Start with consistency.

1. Log every refund and dispute
2. Tag the reason
3. Split refunds between deferred revenue vs contra revenue
4. Record entries in the same month
5. Review refund and dispute rates monthly

When you can walk into a fundraise with clean AI usage metrics, refund rates, and dispute data, you look like the team that understands its own billing engine.